How hard is finding a needle in a haystack? Maths answers
A University of Toronto statistician walks through the odds of finding a needle in a haystack: roughly 35 hours of searching and a 23% daily chance.
The old saying about finding a needle in a haystack suggests an almost impossible task. A Scientific American piece in its "No Dumb Questions" series, published November 7, asks how impossible it really is and turns to probability for an answer.
An expert's verdict
Jeffrey Rosenthal, a statistics professor at the University of Toronto, says the task is "very, very hard." The problem falls under probability theory, which Rosenthal describes as the mathematical study of randomness and uncertainty.
Sizing up the haystack
The article assumes a haystack about 3 feet wide, 3 feet long and 8 feet high, or roughly 125,000 cubic inches. For comparison, the interior of a Honda Civic is about 171,000 cubic inches.
A systematic search
Rosenthal suggests dividing the haystack into one-cubic-inch pieces and checking each one. At a pace of one cubic inch per second, searching the whole stack would take about 35 hours.
- Each piece has a 1-in-125,000 chance of containing the needle.
- The needle could turn up in the very first piece, or the search could stretch to almost a day and a half.
- Because people need to eat and sleep, Rosenthal suggests limiting searching to 8 hours a day, which gives about a 23% chance of finding the needle each day.
Could flattening help?
One alternative is to convert the stack into a flat mat, which might make each piece easier to search. But the mat would be much larger and wider, and Rosenthal says this creates new challenges of its own.
Needles, machine learning and AI
The idea is not only a figure of speech for mathematicians. Machine-learning researchers study needle-in-a-haystack problems, training models to tell a needle apart from its surroundings. According to the article, most of this work uses the phrase as an analogy rather than describing an actual search through straw.
Looking ahead, Rosenthal notes that AI has helped solve some difficult math problems but has not been used much for probability yet. "I'm sure it's coming," he says.
The takeaway is a reassuring one for anyone who has ever faced a seemingly hopeless search: broken into small, systematic steps, even a daunting task becomes a matter of arithmetic. The needle may be hard to find, but the odds can at least be calculated.
Sources
Written with automated tools from the sources above and published without editor review. Spotted an error? Tell us · Corrections Policy
Related stories
SpaceX catches Starship from orbit for the first time
SpaceX's launch tower arms caught a Starship upper stage returning from orbit on November 14, a first for the programme. The booster was lost after engine trouble, so the planned double catch did not happen.
Experts vet OpenAI's AI-made Yang-Mills proof, with limits
A review group says OpenAI's AI-generated proof builds a quantum Yang-Mills theory, checked in Lean. It does not prove the mass gap, and reviewers say they do not yet fully understand it.
Geologists link Earth's missing rock layer to deep mantle
A Nature study modelled mantle motion to explain the Great Unconformity, suggesting uplifted continents were eroded, possibly by Snowball Earth glaciers.
Astronomers weigh a 'Planet Nine' candidate in old data
A team combing 1980s and 2000s infrared surveys flagged one possible distant world, but its steep orbit does not match the long-proposed Planet Nine, writes astronomer Phil Plait.
