The Daily Ledger

ScienceNews

Physicists say no material can be fully transparent

A theoretical study argues a quantum process turns light into sound waves, so even the clearest material must eventually dim light.

The Daily Ledger Staff · Updated 3 min read

Even the clearest material imaginable cannot let all light through, according to a new theoretical result described by Scientific American on November 7, 2026. A group of physicists argues that a quantum process converts light into sound waves, setting a fundamental limit on transparency.

The clearest materials today

Guinness World Records credits Ivan Smalyukh with inventing the most transparent material known. His lab at the University of Colorado Boulder developed gels, tuned to bend light very little, that could serve as window insulation, and they are clearer than glass itself. But the gels work well only as thin layers; a foot-thick layer would transmit very little light. Fibre-optic cables, by contrast, carry light along bending paths for miles before it needs amplification, including cables that link the internet across oceans.

A theoretical ceiling

Theoretical physicists Alberto Nicolis, Federico Piazza and Angelo Esposito asked how much light the most transparent possible material would lose. Such a material would have to be cold, so that thermal motion does not absorb light, and chemically inert, so that reactions or electric currents do not absorb it. They still expected some photons to be absorbed through subtle quantum effects. The team posted its work as a preprint on arXiv.org on October 8.

Their model uses superfluid helium. Cooled to a few degrees above absolute zero, helium becomes a superfluid that flows without friction. Liquid helium is already extremely clear; it absorbs X-rays, but scientists have not measured any effect on visible light.

How light fades

The idea came from Esposito's earlier work on dark matter. He had been looking for a hypothetical particle called a dark photon, which could be detected if it nudged an atomic nucleus in superfluid helium. He realised ordinary photons should behave the same way. "In interacting with one of the nuclei, it gives it a kick," Esposito said, according to the article.

Each kick creates a quantum sound wave, or vibration. Over repeated interactions, the photon loses energy until it becomes undetectable. In the idealised superfluid, light could cross Earth's diameter before becoming noticeably fainter, yet it still fades eventually.

Beyond helium

The model describes superfluids specifically, but the researchers expect similar rules to apply elsewhere. "I think it's universal for all materials," Esposito said, according to the article. Borna Salehian, a physicist at ETH Zurich who was not involved in the work, praised the paper as identifying a fundamental limit set by nature. "In theoretical physics, we look for fundamental limitations set by nature. This paper precisely gives one!" he said.

The result is theoretical and appeared as a preprint, so it has not necessarily been through peer review. It does not stop engineers from building clearer materials, but it suggests that no design can ever reach perfect transparency.

Sources

This story was prepared with the help of automated drafting tools and was reviewed and fact-checked by our editors before publication. See our Editorial Policy.

Report a problem with this story · Copyright & takedown