Planet Nine candidate: why astronomers remain doubtful
A 2025 claim of a distant planet found in old infrared survey data has drawn criticism, and astronomer Phil Plait says its existence is far from settled.
A hard search
A 2025 claim that astronomers may have found a distant new planet is drawing fresh scrutiny. In a 6 November 2026 Scientific American column, astronomer Phil Plait explains why the candidate's reality remains unclear.
The region beyond Neptune holds billions of small rocky and icy bodies, but it is so vast that these objects rarely pass within a million kilometres of one another. That makes even relatively large objects hard to find. The hypothetical world is nicknamed "Planet Nine", a playful reference to astronomers' 2006 decision to demote Pluto.
How the candidate was found
An international team published a paper in the journal Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia reporting a candidate in the deep trans-Neptunian region. The claim drew modest attention at first, then renewed interest through a BBC Sky at Night Magazine article and social media. Other researchers have criticised it, including two astronomers largely responsible for the original Planet Nine search.
A planet that far from the Sun reflects very little light, and its brightness falls off with the fourth power of its distance from us. Infrared offers a better chance because a cold planet still emits it. The team used data from the Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS), which surveyed the sky in the early 1980s, and Japan's AKARI observatory, which operated for about 18 months in 2006 and 2007. The roughly two-decade gap allowed time for a distant object to show motion.
The researchers searched for objects that appeared at one position in the IRAS data and another in the AKARI data, with the brightness and motion expected of a planet orbiting several hundred times farther from the Sun than Earth. After cross-checking hundreds of thousands of potential objects, they narrowed the field to a single candidate.
Why scientists are sceptical
Plait gives several reasons for doubt:
- Too little data: two points give a crude orbit, but at least one more widely separated point is needed to estimate its shape.
- False positives: faint variable stars or flaring black holes in distant galaxies could produce either detection.
- Wrong tilt: Mike Brown's measurement, reported in Science, puts the candidate's orbital inclination near 120 degrees, while the Planet Nine hypothesis needs about 15 to 20 degrees.
Brown and Konstantin Batygin proposed Planet Nine in 2016 to explain the oddly aligned orbits of several large trans-Neptunian objects. Batygin has suggested calling the new candidate "Planet 8.5", since it would not be their proposed planet even if real.
What comes next
Plait says the Dark Energy Camera and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory could test the candidate. Rubin announced a possible dwarf planet, 2026 ED138, in October 2026; it is at least 600 km wide with an orbit of roughly 280 Earth years. Plait cautions that Rubin's data could also undercut both the 2025 claim and the original proposal. His bottom line: "we don't know if either of these planets exists", and only continued observation can settle it.
Sources
Written with automated tools from the sources above and published without editor review. Spotted an error? Tell us · Corrections Policy
Related stories
SpaceX catches Starship from orbit for the first time
SpaceX's launch tower arms caught a Starship upper stage returning from orbit on November 14, a first for the programme. The booster was lost after engine trouble, so the planned double catch did not happen.
Experts vet OpenAI's AI-made Yang-Mills proof, with limits
A review group says OpenAI's AI-generated proof builds a quantum Yang-Mills theory, checked in Lean. It does not prove the mass gap, and reviewers say they do not yet fully understand it.
Geologists link Earth's missing rock layer to deep mantle
A Nature study modelled mantle motion to explain the Great Unconformity, suggesting uplifted continents were eroded, possibly by Snowball Earth glaciers.
Astronomers weigh a 'Planet Nine' candidate in old data
A team combing 1980s and 2000s infrared surveys flagged one possible distant world, but its steep orbit does not match the long-proposed Planet Nine, writes astronomer Phil Plait.
