Researchers trace once-a-minute grid dips to batteries
Researchers say synchronized state-of-charge checks by internet-connected batteries, including data centre UPS units, explain tiny grid frequency dips every minute worldwide.
For years, grid operators around the world have noticed small dips in frequency that recur about once a minute, and that happen at the same moments on grids in different countries and continents. According to a TechCrunch report by Tim De Chant published on 8 November, researchers say they have now identified the cause: batteries that all check their charge on the same schedule.
Why the pattern mattered
A grid must keep its frequency within a narrow range. Large oscillations can lead to blackouts, and even smaller sags can damage equipment, particularly hydropower turbines. The pattern appears in data from Europe, Australia, the United States and Malaysia.
Ruling out hydropower
Tennet Germany, the country's largest transmission system operator, asked Dirk Witthaut of Forschungszentrum Julich to investigate. Hydropower has historically been a major source of ultra-low frequency oscillations, so the team first modelled a hydropower plant control system on the Scandinavian grid. They found conditions that could produce a resonance peaking once per minute. But real resonances typically fade, while these dips persisted minute after minute, leading the team to conclude that something operating on a strict clock was responsible.
The search on campus
The researchers installed more than 80 smart power quality meters around the Julich campus, which has distribution lines, transformers, solar panels, battery storage serving as uninterruptible power supplies and a high-performance computing system. The meters sampled frequency, voltage, current and power every three seconds. The transformer connected to the battery storage system showed a peak every minute, matching the grid-wide pattern.
The culprit
Many stationary batteries, including data centre UPS units and large grid-scale batteries, check their state of charge every minute. Because the devices are internet-connected, their clocks are nearly perfectly synchronised. Each check causes a disturbance too small to notice on a large grid, but when many devices act at once, the combined effect becomes visible.
Evidence from Ireland
Data centres accounted for 18% of the load on Ireland's grid by 2022. Between 2016 and 2021, the minute-by-minute frequency drop there rose from 3 millihertz to 12 millihertz, and some recent drops have exceeded 20. Ireland's 50 Hz grid can tolerate swings of plus or minus 200 millihertz, though the operator prefers to stay within 100. A 20 millihertz dip is modest alone, but if other loads sagged the frequency at the same time, it could push the grid toward blackout conditions.
A simple fix, a hard rollout
The researchers say the problem is entirely preventable: manufacturers of UPS and grid-scale batteries should randomise when devices check their charge rather than doing so exactly on the minute. Tests on internet-connected devices such as a smart oven and Raspberry Pi clusters found similar periodic fluctuations. Those can be fixed with a software patch, but a cited study found fewer than 3% of IoT devices run the latest firmware.
Regulators may need to require changes, but they can only act within their own jurisdictions, so the article argues the global problem will need international coordination. The cause is known, but the dips could persist for years.
Sources
Written with automated tools from the sources above and published without editor review. Spotted an error? Tell us · Corrections Policy
Related stories
SpaceX catches Starship from orbit for the first time
SpaceX's launch tower arms caught a Starship upper stage returning from orbit on November 14, a first for the programme. The booster was lost after engine trouble, so the planned double catch did not happen.
Experts vet OpenAI's AI-made Yang-Mills proof, with limits
A review group says OpenAI's AI-generated proof builds a quantum Yang-Mills theory, checked in Lean. It does not prove the mass gap, and reviewers say they do not yet fully understand it.
Geologists link Earth's missing rock layer to deep mantle
A Nature study modelled mantle motion to explain the Great Unconformity, suggesting uplifted continents were eroded, possibly by Snowball Earth glaciers.
Astronomers weigh a 'Planet Nine' candidate in old data
A team combing 1980s and 2000s infrared surveys flagged one possible distant world, but its steep orbit does not match the long-proposed Planet Nine, writes astronomer Phil Plait.
